Kant-en-klare producten voor jouw natuurlijke routine..
Wil je op de hoogte blijven van voordeel, (win)acties en aanbevelingen? Zo loop je nooit iets mis! Niet irritant vaak, beloofd.
Je kunt je op ieder moment afmelden.
It starts with a familiar email. A customer added Greenservative to her rosewater and xanthan gum gel, and something went wrong. The preservative would not dissolve, and the formula developed an odd smell. She assumed she had made a mistake with the dosage or the method. In reality, she was simply using the right ingredient in the wrong context.
This is a classic recipe versus formula moment. When you understand why a preservative behaves differently in a cream than in a water gel, you stop guessing and start formulating.
Preservatives are not universal. They are designed with a specific phase compatibility in mind. Greenservative is built for emulsions, meaning creams and lotions that contain both an oil and a water phase. In that environment, it can distribute properly and do its job.
When you add a preservative optimized for emulsions to a water only system like rosewater thickened with xanthan gum, there is no oil phase to help it integrate. The preservative cannot fully dissolve into the water. Instead, it sits in the formula undissolved, often creating concentrated pockets that smell strange and leave the rest of the product unprotected. The issue is not the quality of the preservative. The issue is the mismatch between the preservative's design and your formula's architecture.
Microorganisms need water to grow. That means your preservative must be present and active in the water phase. If it cannot dissolve there, it cannot protect there.
The next time you reach for a preservative, stop and ask yourself just one question: am I making an emulsion with oil and water, or am I making a water based product?
An emulsion needs a preservative that functions across oil and water boundaries, or one that is specifically suited to emulsion systems. A water based product, which includes anything from a simple floral water to a xanthan gel with no oil, needs a preservative that is designed to function in a purely aqueous environment.
Malou highlighted two options that fit this second category: Preservative Eco 1388 and Leusidal. These are formulated to remain stable and active in aqueous surroundings, which is why they integrate cleanly into a rosewater gel instead of floating around undissolved.
The original mistake was not a failure of technique. It was a mismatch of categories. This is the core difference between following a recipe and understanding a formula. Recipe thinking says: "I need a preservative, so I will grab the natural one on my shelf." Formula thinking says: "I need a preservative that is soluble and active in the specific phase system I am building."
If your formula contains no oil, your preservative must be able to work without one. That is the rule.
Water based formulas are some of the simplest products to make, but they demand the same respectful formulation logic as complex emulsions. Match your preservative to your phase system, and you move from hoping your product stays stable to knowing it will.
Do you have a water based formula you are trying to preserve? Share your question in our community. We love untangling these formulation puzzles together.
